Discussion by NotebookLM
NS-31: A Missed Opportunity in the Shadow of Inspiration4
When Blue Origin’s NS-31 mission launched on April 14, 2025, it was marketed as a historic milestone: an all-female crew aboard a commercial suborbital flight, a symbolic breakthrough in diversity and representation in space travel. On paper, this initiative had all the hallmarks of genuine inspiration—a narrative of inclusion, empowerment, and accessibility. Instead, what transpired felt less groundbreaking and more like an exercise in superficial spectacle.
Theater of the Absurd: "Rigorous Training"
A significant source of criticism surrounding NS-31 was the exaggerated portrayal of the crew's "rigorous training." Commentators waxed poetic about preparation as though these women had endured the kind of intense astronaut conditioning seen in NASA programs. In reality, the training lasted only a few days, mainly focusing on mundane tasks such as entering and exiting the spacecraft, buckling safety harnesses, and learning basic procedures. While there's nothing inherently wrong with the minimal nature of this training—indeed, its simplicity is a testament to technological progress—the insistence on inflating these simple tasks into acts of heroism became absurdly transparent.
The crew—Katy Perry, Gayle King, Lauren Sánchez, Amanda Nguyen, Aisha Bowe, and Kerianne Flynn—were presented as modern-day Neil Armstrongs, a narrative that many found disingenuous. Instead of highlighting accessibility and simplicity as strengths, the mission's marketers tried to manufacture gravitas through melodramatic rhetoric and carefully choreographed moments. Consequently, what should have been an empowering milestone felt reduced to celebrity indulgence masquerading as exploration.
Historical Context and the Legacy of Space Tourism
Suborbital space tourism is not a novel concept. The idea dates back to the X-15 rocket-powered aircraft flights in the 1960s, where pilots briefly reached space before descending back to Earth. These early missions were genuine feats of aeronautical skill and technological advancement, setting benchmarks for future human space endeavors. Decades later, entrepreneurs like Sir Richard Branson (Virgin Galactic) and Jeff Bezos (Blue Origin) reignited public imagination by investing heavily in private space tourism, aiming to democratize space travel by making it accessible and routine.
Blue Origin's New Shepard rocket, notably clean and efficient, produces only water vapor as a byproduct, showcasing a commitment to environmental responsibility and sustainability. New Shepard successfully established itself as a pioneering technology, demonstrating safe, repeatable, and environmentally-friendly suborbital flights.
Despite these commendable achievements, NS-31 overlooked the valuable lessons from earlier suborbital missions. For instance, Virgin Galactic's early flights emphasized ease, enjoyment, and safety, setting realistic expectations without unnecessary embellishment. Blue Origin had the chance to follow a similar path, highlighting their reliable technology and how effortlessly civilians could experience space. Instead, they diverged into needless hyperbole, emphasizing dramatized heroics and thus undermining their own strengths.
Optics Over Opportunity
NS-31 genuinely had all the ingredients of a powerful, inspirational story. A group of accomplished women experiencing space travel could have symbolized a genuine democratization of space. Instead, Blue Origin opted for spectacle, elevating style over substance. The mission lasted approximately 11 minutes, only a few of which involved weightlessness, yet was packaged as a groundbreaking, pioneering achievement. This exaggeration not only invited mockery but actively undermined the mission’s potential impact. Instead of inspiring the next generation of explorers, it alienated the very audience it aimed to captivate.
Historically, space exploration has inspired generations precisely because it was authentically challenging and meaningful. The Apollo missions, the Space Shuttle program, and even private endeavors such as SpaceX's earlier achievements fostered genuine enthusiasm through honest portrayals of risk, effort, and human perseverance. NS-31's portrayal lacked this authenticity, reducing what could have been an impactful event into a trivialized celebrity spectacle.
Inspiration4: How To Get It Right
In sharp contrast, consider SpaceX’s Inspiration4 mission, launched in 2021. Unlike NS-31, Inspiration4 delivered meaningful storytelling through genuine preparation and a clear philanthropic goal. The four civilian crew members, notably including Hayley Arceneaux—a cancer survivor and medical professional—underwent extensive training over several months, dealing with actual spaceflight risks, physical conditioning, and emergency simulations. Crucially, the mission raised over $200 million for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, grounding its narrative in human connection and authentic purpose.
Inspiration4’s approach succeeded precisely because it didn't posture or inflate its significance artificially. It didn't need to. The mission inherently demonstrated that space was accessible to everyday people driven by meaningful purposes, not just the wealthy or famous. It invited viewers to imagine themselves in space, not through celebrity glamour but through empathy, sincerity, and compelling human stories.
Lessons from Past Missions
Reflecting further on space tourism’s history, earlier private missions like Dennis Tito’s groundbreaking 2001 space tourism trip to the International Space Station offered authentic narratives of genuine training and human courage. Tito, a civilian engineer, underwent months of extensive training with NASA and the Russian space agency, setting the tone for future space tourists.
Even SpaceX’s subsequent private missions to the International Space Station continued the tradition of serious, purposeful engagement with space exploration, involving participants who trained extensively and participated meaningfully in research or philanthropy. By contrast, Blue Origin's NS-31 ignored these historical precedents, instead focusing on manufactured spectacle rather than embracing the inherent simplicity and accessibility of their mission.
The Road Not Taken
The missed opportunity with NS-31 is particularly stark when considering the technological achievements underlying the mission. Blue Origin's reliable, reusable suborbital platform is impressive and genuinely important for the future of space travel. It provides a straightforward, safe experience accessible to virtually anyone with minimal preparation. Rather than emphasizing this revolutionary accessibility, Blue Origin chose spectacle over sincerity. They created a lavish, hollow narrative that prioritized celebrity status and media buzz over substance and authentic storytelling.
Had NS-31 been framed transparently—as a testament to how routine space travel has become, as a step forward in making space accessible to all—it might have resonated more profoundly. It could have been used as a platform for education, STEM encouragement, or philanthropic causes, just as Inspiration4 did so effectively. Instead, it devolved into a missed chance, easily dismissed as little more than extravagant PR.
Conclusion: Simplicity is Revolutionary
Ultimately, the flaw in NS-31 wasn't that it was easy. The flaw was pretending it was difficult, obscuring the true narrative that genuinely deserved attention. Space travel has reached a point where regular people—famous or not—can safely and quickly venture to the edge of space. That simplicity and accessibility should be celebrated, not hidden behind layers of manufactured complexity.
Blue Origin’s NS-31 mission could have embraced simplicity to profound effect. Instead, they offered theatrics and superficiality, squandering an opportunity to inspire genuine public enthusiasm. In doing so, NS-31 became a stark illustration of how not to present the future of space exploration.
Inspiration4, by contrast, illustrated how meaningful storytelling and authentic experiences resonate with the public. Blue Origin would do well to remember this lesson in future missions: genuine narratives always outshine manufactured spectacle.
Thank you for your time today. Until next time, stay curious and gruntled.
Do you like what you read but aren’t yet ready or able to get a paid subscription? Then consider a one-time tip at:
https://www.venmo.com/u/TheCogitatingCeviche
Ko-fi.com/thecogitatingceviche
Share this post